Why Your Shift Isn’t Getting Filled (And How to Fix It)

By SODT Team

Why Your Shift Isn’t Getting Filled (And How to Fix It)

If you’ve ever posted a shift and struggled to get it filled, you’re not alone.

The good news? In most cases, it’s not a lack of dental professionals — it’s a few small factors that make a big difference.

After completing 1,600+ shifts across Southern Ontario, we’ve seen exactly what works… and what doesn’t.

Here’s what may be holding your shift back — and how to fix it.

If you want to dive deeper into how temping improves efficiency and coverage, check out:
👉 https://sodentaltemps.ca/dental-temp-agency-improve-efficiency/
👉 https://sodentaltemps.ca/dental-temp-agency-sick-call-ins/

1. Short Notice vs. Optimal Notice

The biggest factor in whether your shift gets filled is timing.

The more notice you give, the better your chances. Based on our internal data, shifts with more notice consistently perform better — with 15–30 days notice reaching ~80% fill rates and 30+ days reaching ~85%, compared to significantly lower rates for last-minute postings.

When shifts are posted last-minute, dental professionals may already be booked or have made other plans.

How to fix it:

  • Aim to post shifts at least 1–2 weeks in advance when possible
  • If it’s last-minute, make sure the rest of your posting is strong (pay, clarity, etc.)

2. Pay Rate Matters

Dental professionals are evaluating multiple opportunities — and compensation plays a role.

If your rate is below market, your shift may get passed over.

How to fix it:

  • Stay competitive with current market rates
  • Consider slightly higher rates for short-notice or harder-to-fill days

For a deeper breakdown of cost vs value, see:
👉 https://sodentaltemps.ca/dental-temp-agency-vs-hiring-in-house-what-costs-less-long-term/

3. Day of the Week

Not all days are equal.

From our internal data:

  • Mid-day shifts on Tuesday and Wednesday tend to be harder to fill, with fill rates around 65–70%
  • Mondays, Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays perform stronger, often reaching 80%+ fill rates

This comes down to availability patterns and scheduling preferences.

How to fix it:

  • Post earlier for Tuesday/Wednesday mid-day shifts
  • Strengthen your posting (pay, clarity, preparation) for harder time slots
  • Take advantage of higher-performing days when planning ahead

4. Location

Geography plays a bigger role than most expect.

If your practice is in a less central, more rural, or harder-to-reach area, it can naturally reduce the number of available applicants. Travel time, traffic, and accessibility all factor into a dental professional’s decision when applying to a shift.

How to fix it:

  • Provide more notice to give professionals time to plan ahead
  • Offer a slightly higher rate to make the shift more attractive
  • Clearly communicate parking, traffic considerations, and ease of access

When location is a factor, combining more time + stronger compensation is often the difference between a shift sitting unfilled and getting picked up quickly.

5. Poor or Vague Shift Descriptions

Uncertainty creates hesitation.

If a dental professional doesn’t know what to expect, they’re less likely to apply.

How to fix it:

Include details like:

  • Software used
  • Type of patients
  • Any unique workflows
  • What support is available

Bonus (highly recommended):
We provide an area within our web app for practices to upload a PDF outlining office operations that temps can review ahead of time.

This document can include:

  • Common codes used
  • What to do during downtime
  • Where stock and supplies are located
  • How to set up X-rays / take a pan
  • Expectations that go beyond standard shift details

This removes uncertainty and helps professionals walk in prepared — improving both fill rates and repeat bookings.

6. Slow Response Time to Applicants

This is one of the most overlooked — and most important — factors.

Dental professionals often apply to multiple shifts.
If they don’t hear back quickly, they’ll accept another opportunity.

They don’t want to wait around wondering if they’ve been selected.

How to fix it:

  • Review applicants as soon as possible
  • Be ready to move quickly when you see a strong candidate

Speed = securing your preferred temp.

Offices like https://www.essexsmiles.ca/, https://hakimdental.com/, and https://www.sdfamilydentistry.com/ are quick to respond securing shifts.

7. The First 30 Minutes of the Shift (This Impacts Future Fill Rates)**

Getting a shift filled isn’t just about today — it affects your ability to fill shifts in the future.

If a dental professional has a great experience, they’re far more likely to return.

And one of the biggest factors?
How the day starts.

If a temp arrives and:

  • No one is there to greet them
  • There’s no tour
  • They feel unprepared

…it creates a stressful experience.

How to fix it:

  • Have someone ready at the agreed arrival time
  • Provide a quick tour of the office
  • Set clear expectations for the day

This directly increases the likelihood of repeat professionals, making future shifts significantly easier to fill.

8. Speed of Payment

This is another major factor in whether dental professionals return to your practice.

Professionals value fast, reliable payment — it builds trust and makes your office more attractive for future shifts.

How to fix it:

  • Ensure payments are processed quickly and consistently

We also have solutions coming soon built directly into our web app to help streamline and improve payment speed even further — making the process easier for both practices and professionals.

Final Thoughts

Filling a shift isn’t just about posting it — it’s about:

  • Timing
  • Communication
  • Experience
  • Follow-through

When you get these right, everything becomes easier:

  • Faster fill rates
  • Better professionals
  • More consistent coverage

To see how we’ve scaled this across Southern Ontario:
👉 https://sodentaltemps.ca/celebrating-1000-shifts-across-southern-ontario/
👉 https://sodentaltemps.ca/dental-temp-shifts-ontario/

✅ Want to Get Your Next Shift Filled Faster?

Focus on these key areas:

  • Post early
  • Stay competitive
  • Respond quickly
  • Set your temp up for success
  • Create an experience they want to come back to

Because when a professional has a great day at your office…
they don’t just fill one shift — they come back for more.

Related Posts